This post indicates that our concerns have been heard. Give them a chance. Clearly discussions are taking place and some changes will be made. Whether those changes will be acceptable to the community can only be judged after we have seen them; but in view of this post it is most unfair to say that our concerns have not been heard. Why do you suppose they used the megaphone graphic?
This post indicates that our concerns have been heard. Give them a chance.
They've had three months, they've had their chance. They squandered it.
in view of this post it is most unfair to say that our concerns have not been heard
In view of their complete failure to fix the known bugs in the Beta, let alone to materially alter a fundamentally flawed design... it's quite fair to say that our concerns have not been heard. From this and corporatespeak nature of timothy's post, it's quite clear that th
I think they understand the magnitude of their "failure" which isn't a failure in their eyes. They bought/., but they clearly don't want/., so they are going to demolish it and build something new.
It's not like you can "fix" the beta, because every single thing about it that is different from the site as it is now is wrong. I'm not talking from an aesthetic point of view, although aesthetically, the beta is like goat sick, but it systematically demolishes every piece of functionality that makes/. good.
They do not care about the existing user base. What they care about is the potential that they see for the brand name "Slashdot". They will happily lose us all in order to try and get what they think they can get without realizing they're poisoning the well.
When it doesn't happen and it completely tanks, well, none of us will be surprised. But then we won't be here anymore. Sites like what they're trying to make are a dime a dozen and name recognition means next to nothing when you do not have an existing user base, or worse, when you've done like they're doing now and actively driven away your users.
Why? (Score:5, Insightful)
Re: (Score:5, Insightful)
This post indicates that our concerns have been heard. Give them a chance. Clearly discussions are taking place and some changes will be made. Whether those changes will be acceptable to the community can only be judged after we have seen them; but in view of this post it is most unfair to say that our concerns have not been heard. Why do you suppose they used the megaphone graphic?
Re: (Score:2)
They've had three months, they've had their chance. They squandered it.
In view of their complete failure to fix the known bugs in the Beta, let alone to materially alter a fundamentally flawed design... it's quite fair to say that our concerns have not been heard. From this and corporatespeak nature of timothy's post, it's quite clear that th
Re: (Score:2)
I think they understand the magnitude of their "failure" which isn't a failure in their eyes. They bought /., but they clearly don't want /., so they are going to demolish it and build something new.
It's not like you can "fix" the beta, because every single thing about it that is different from the site as it is now is wrong. I'm not talking from an aesthetic point of view, although aesthetically, the beta is like goat sick, but it systematically demolishes every piece of functionality that makes /. good.
Re:Why? (Score:2)
They do not care about the existing user base. What they care about is the potential that they see for the brand name "Slashdot". They will happily lose us all in order to try and get what they think they can get without realizing they're poisoning the well.
When it doesn't happen and it completely tanks, well, none of us will be surprised. But then we won't be here anymore. Sites like what they're trying to make are a dime a dozen and name recognition means next to nothing when you do not have an existing user base, or worse, when you've done like they're doing now and actively driven away your users.